Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Kanban On The Fridge Door

Perhaps in your case it is different, but when my family grew bigger, I started to have a backlog of household tasks. In fact, I couldn’t make it, my task lists were bursting at the seams and frightened me with prompts every five minutes or so. As we all know, backlog leads to another backlog. The more you try to put something off, the more afraid you become. The more afraid you become, the easier you put it aside, etc. This is the initial stage that I was in.

Stage 1: What is really going on?

So I determined to do something about it. Although I did not have any idea what exactly would change, I thought to myself that if I did something – anything, whatever – at least I would see if it helped or not. Than I would have at least one thing less to test.

To gather more information, I talked with a colleague of mine who has a couple of years of experience in bringing up two children. She gave me the following hints:
  • Lack of time is not a consequence of you having children or not having them. Lack of time results from the number of things that you cannot foresee. Therefore, be more precise in your foresight.
  • Don’t add up tasks to your everyday routines. Instead, you should plan and complete one task, because if you start doing seven things at the same time, you will end up having them unfinished and you will definitely feel irritated that you haven’t done anything.
  • Keep your things always in the same place. Take this example: the night comes and you have to change the nappy. You start looking for it everywhere, make a lot of noise and wake the baby up. And this is the end of your night, thank you, now you can only dream of yourself sleeping, not to mention the tot. Therefore, always keep your things in the same place. After you have done 3 steps with your eyes closed, you have to have all the necessary equipment at your elbow.
  • Sometimes you just won’t be able to do anything. Accept it.
After some consideration I came up with the following rules of conduct: plan, limit your WIP, improve your flow, be more self-understanding. And that’s how my thoughts reached Kanban.

I came home like a whirlwind and the only thing that I could think about was to paper the kitchen walls to visualize the work process. The negotiations with my wife ended up with me having the fridge door at my sole disposal. Ok, it’s better than a poke in the eye. The first board had three columns: TO DO, IN PROGRESS, DONE.

I took action.

First effects

The change was really huge. I couldn’t pass by the IN PROGRESS sticky notes indifferently. Oh, I just couldn’t. Due to the fact that I see my fridge every day, I did not have to write the start date and monitor the progress with any special attention. I just knew when my tasks got stuck and I felt that it was just too long.

What is more, it turned out that tasks I had postponed earlier, seemed more frightening than they really were. For example: when my daughter was born I was already for some time engaged into bringing order to my documents that I had decided to thematically group in folders. For about 5 months I did not have time to finish it. This thing really bothered me and I estimated that I would need at least one whole weekend to complete this tasks. When the time for this sticky not came, it turned out that… the documents were already in order and I just had forgotten about it. Really! When I stopped working with those papers, I just didn’t complete this task in my head, so it still bothered me. When I started doing it again, after 10 minutes I felt proud to put this sticky note in the DONE column.

I started to catch up on my backlog and within two months I was there – with no overdue tasks to do.

Stage 2: Where is business value?

One evening it occurred that it all didn’t work as good as I thought. My wife told me that she saw that I did complete my tasks and that I really cared, but for her nothing changed.
-Umm… How is that possible?, I asked.
-Nothing changed. I still don’t have enough sleep, I am tired. she said showing me her task list in GoogleTask. And I don’t have time for anything. You do your job, but it does not change our situation.

And then I experienced enlightenment once again: our situation. How could I forget about it? A family is the most natural kind of team on earth! When one member of this team performs, the others get stuck. It became clear that we need to use the pull model.
My wife got her pile of orange sticky notes and I asked her to put some tasks on the board. We agreed that we would deal with them whenever any of us would have time. That is how our improved version of board came into being. The board finally involved the entire team – not only me.

Then I started to think how I should know that everything is OK. How to notice that we deal with the “right” tasks – how to recognize our business value? Due to the fact that I did not know how to identify it and I did not want to create anything artificial, I decided to start with the issues that I discussed with my wife. I decided to measure our business value with two questions:
  • Do I have time to myself?
  • Do I feel tired?
Because of the fact that my team does not feel convinced to (and interested in) the Fibonacci number and consecutive two squares, I decided to use smile index that you can see on the image.

That was a go! Both me and my wife could intuitively measure the business value of our team. We still do it – from time to time, when we walk through the kitchen, we show the level of satisfaction that we currently feel. As you can see on the image, there is some progress :)

The questions that I mentioned are also useful when we need to decide if a given task should be done now. Assuming that we will do it now, will it turn out that we have more time and we feel less tired?

Stage 3: The value stream appears

We reached the point at which our expenses rocketed. We just went too far and we realized that it wasn’t the only month that we went too far with our spending Although I used, this issue just slipped by. I was wondering how it was possible that I had had no control over our expenses. I realized that some bills had waited to be recorded for so long that the month would already be over and I either still did not have them there or I tried to catch up with recording them in a hurry.

I came to a conclusion that we have to change it as well and keep our financial activity under control. I came up with an idea of an additional swimline called FINANCES. Now that my wife felt somehow committed to this teamwork, she agreed to relocate the board from the fridge to the wall.

So we formally introduced the BACKLOG section and items from this group are regularly evaluated and we move them to the WORTH DOING section. We divided the IN PROGRESS column into three parts: FOR NOW, FOR TODAY, PENDING. We have also added the already mentioned FINANCE swimline

The new board has become more transparent, which gave us a wider perspective and… a new quality. I have soon noticed that some tasks are distinguishing in comparison to others – they are as if bigger, and when we complete them, they do not bring any major consequences. Consider the following tasks:
  • Fix the bathtub baseboard
  • Register the expenses
  • Buy tickets for a trip to the brother-in-law
and compare them with these:
  • Organize holidays
  • Find a new flat
  • Find a new flat

Urgency and importance rediscovered

Obviously, the second group of tasks implies something bigger to be done and I am aware of that. But you know what, you won’t see it until you notice it. Look at the picture below. Those fat tasks are put on violet sticky notes and I circled them in red.

For a couple of months I was working with the board, but when I finally saw it as a whole, when I saw the map of my work, I noticed the difference between these types of tasks. I noticed it in a different way than I used to notice it. I felt it to the bone. Take a look at it and you will see that the number of violet sticky notes is small if compared to the rest. It is incredible to see how many other things wait to be done and how hard it is to decide which are the priority. Those most important ones make up the so called value stream. For some of them it would be good to open a separate swimline or create a separate table.

The thing is that when you complete tasks day after day, all the tasks that you are engaged in here and now seem important – you have to complete it.
How can you not buy a ticket for a trip to the brother-in-law? Once you see everything that you do on the table, when you see the entire process of your work, you start to see some patterns. In your life you finally start to feel things that you only knew about. It has a great impact on your motivation, time management and awareness of what is important and what is not, which in turn enables you to develop a crucial skill – the ability to resign.

Additionally, we have placed a new and experimental visual representation of our spending., as I have already mentioned, is a very handy tool to keep a retrospective control of our expenses, but currently I am searching for some methods to have a prospective control. But this is another cup of tea :)

What have I learnt?

First: don’t try to come up with a great upfront solution. You need time to start noticing what you really deal with. However, you should remember that to notice you need to look at, examine and visualize your work.

Second: even in a well-knit team any change takes place gradually. It’s nice that you have a vision, but others may not share it. Start from small things, show that they work and support them with some new practices. Start from the fridge. If it works, you will soon end up having the wall :)

One more thing about urgency and importance

I have the impression that it is all not about something like: how to avoid urgent and unimportant tasks or how to delegate them (since we do not have any subordinates). It really often happens that all in all you have to complete these tasks (hands up who’s not cleaning at home?). Usually the number of such tasks is so great that you run out of time to deal with the “bigger” ones. The whole idea is about finding time for some rare important tasks. It is about completing the urgent ones without neglecting the important ones.

Kanban vs. GTD

For a number of years as my main framework I used Getting Things Done. GTD is exactly about getting things done. When you use it, you do everything that you deem important. GTD does not allow to set priorities the way we understand it. Instead, it focuses on the ways to optimize your activity through an emphasis on a clear definition of actions that you need to take, contexts in which you have to take them, and the optimal procedures that will allow you to work.

In contrast, Kanban gives you a perspective and, according to the author of the Personal Kanban book, an instant kinesthetic feedback. You see your own business process, which gives you a chance to analyze and revise it – and, of course, a lot of satisfaction from putting the sticky notes in various columns:)

I still see the great value of GTD. It really defines a lot of detailed techniques that are missing in Kanban. Here you will find a good comparison. Not to repeat myself I will just list those things that I would like to enrich my Kanban with:
  • Definition of actions to be taken; a task has to be actionable, because then it is easier to complete
  • Decomposition of tasks to make them unambiguous (more information about this technique is presented in the chapter about specification in this book)
  • Very “thick” division of actions which makes them more actionable
  • Work according to FIFO
  • Brainstorming
  • Work contexts
  • Fresh head :)
These are the major elements. I really encourage you to read both David Allen’s book and Jim Benson’s book. However, please remember that to have the knowledge does not mean the same as to know how to use the knowledge.


  1. Świetnie! Co do planowania perspektywicznego. Ja używam Google Docsowego excela. Od 3 lat planujemy razem wydatki każdego miesiąca jak i w przyszłości. Dzięki temu wiemy na co i ile wydaliśmy w danym miesiącu jak i wiemy ile średnio miesięcznie wydajemy na dodatkowe rzeczy, które trzeba kupić i tę wartość planuje z góry na każdy miesiąc do przodu. Trochę to trwało, ale teraz jestem w stanie z dużą dozą prawdopodobieństwa powiedzieć w styczniu ile będę miał pieniędzy w grudniu :-)

  2. @Leszek

    A jak organizujesz się z wpisywaniem kwot bieżących wydatków? Dla mnie jest to najbardziej uciążliwe. Tyle tego jest...:)

  3. mimo wszystko proponuję nie mieszać pracy zawodowej z życiem prywatnym. zostawmy życiu trochę spontaniczności i chaosu, bo za chwilę to się skończy stand-up meetingami z żoną co rano. ;-)

    a tak już na serio, to widziałem już kilka wpisów na różnych blogach z życiowymi implementacjami Kanbana i zacząłem odnosić wrażenie, że ludzie zaczęli widzieć wszystkie problemy, jak gwóźdź, gdy nauczyli się posługiwać młotkiem o nazwie Kanban. Jak jest w tym przypadku- nie wiem. :-) to, o czym warto pamiętać, to to, że Kanban miał oryginalnie modelować pracę przy taśmie produkcyjnej i proces typu pull, ale to są już trochę filozoficzne rozważania. Ja jestem zwilennikiem metodologii "whatever works"

  4. Bardzo dobre! Dobry pomysł, solidny wpis. Inspiruje. :-)

    Z GTD mam jedną naukę: Wszystkie rzeczy gdzieś zapisz, otaguj i co jakiś czas przeglądaj.

    Masz chwilę - spróbuj którąś z nich zaatakować "przy okazji". Czasem zrób przegląd i zastanów się nad dłuższą perspektywą. Do obu tych zadań warto mieć je zapisane, choćby po to żeby nic nie umknęło i żeby łatwo było to ogarnąć.

    I jeszcze: Wyrzucenie wszystkiego z głowy do jakiegoś zewnętrznego, zaufanego systemu drastycznie obniża stres i poprawia koncentrację.

    Kanban czy GTD, w takim codziennym zakresie sprowadza się do tego samego i ma podobne zalety. W GTD fajna jest "totalność": miejsce na dłuższą perspektywę, tagi/listy...

  5. @Tomek Pająk

    Dzięki za komentarz. Nie jestem znawcą tematu, ale wyobrażam sobie, że istnieje więcej niż jeden sposób, na osiągnięcie tego stanu regularnej satysfakcji, który potocznie nazywamy szczęściem. Ten jest mój, aczkolwiek nikogo nie zmuszam do naśladowania:)


  6. Świetny post. Gratuluję zaangażowania i pomysłowości. Personal Kanban ma rzesze zwolenników na całym świecie. Wywodzi wprost z metody Kanban, ale nie kanbana produkcyjnego dobrze znanego w Polsce, a metodologii do zarządzania procesem wytwarzania oprogramowania. Oczywiście, pan Tomek Pająk ma rację, nie można dać się zwariować i na siłę próbować zorganizować swoje życie według reguł funkcjonowania przedsiębiorstwa. Aby nasze życie było ciekawe należy zachować spontaniczność, podejmować ryzykowne decyzje i starać się wycisnąć każdą chwile jak cytrynę. Nie można jednak odmówić tablicy Kanban skuteczności w odniesieniu do organizacji obowiązków domowych, a więc spraw, wobec których spontaniczne podejście nie koniecznie jest dobrym pomysłem (opłaty, sprawy urzędowe, organizacja przyjęć, specjalne okazje o których nie można zapomnieć - urodziny teściowej, imieniny babci). Sam mam taką niewielka tablicę, ale tylko z ważnymi sprawami, które ogranicza jasny deadline. Cieszy, że coraz więcej osób w Polsce sięga po metody i narzędzia mające ułatwiać organizację czasu w domu i w pracy, zwiększać świadomość priorytetów i celowości działań oraz podnosić produktywność pracy. Szczególnie ważne jest to, aby polskie przedsiębiorstwa chętniej wykorzystywały tego typu rozwiązania i starały się dogonić w tej kwestii firmy zachodnie. Pracowałem w kilku firmach IT w Niemczech. W niemal każdej z nich wykorzystaliśmy webowe narzędzia do organizacji pracy takie, jak Banana Scrum, Agile Zen i moja ulubiona Kanban Tool. Zachęcam do własnych poszukiwań tego typu aplikacji. Są na prawdę pomocne, pod warunkiem, że korzystanie z nich nie zostanie "sformalizowane" i utrudnione przez kierownictwo. Niezbędnym składnikiem sukcesu metod zarządzania procesami/zadaniami jest odpowiednie podejście całej organizacji. Dotyczy to również wdrażania Kanbana do organizacji obowiązków domowych;)

  7. Z mojej strony mogę polecić .

    Intuicyjnie mam jeszcze wątpliwość z wykorzystaniem Kanbana do procesów, które składają się z trzech kolumn "Do zrobienia", "W trakcie wykonywania", "zrobione" - trochę pachnie to dla mnie armatą na wróbla. ;) Z drugiej strony nie należy też na siłę wymyślać pośrednich stanów. Wydaje mi się, że najważniejszą rzeczą wynikającą z wprowadzenia tablicy Kanbanowej jest wizualizacja procesu i *wnioski* płynącę z obserwacji tej tablicy w czasie: zabawa WIP limitem, identyfikacja wąskich gardeł i szukanie miejsca na optymalizację.